Mathematics > Computation

I enjoy browsing the TED video collection, which includes a series of talks by “thinkers and doers” in the areas of technology, entertainment, and design (hence the acronym “TED”). Similar to the five-minute Ignite talks that Key Curriculum Press hosts at various math conferences, TED presentations challenge their speakers to give the “talk of their lives in 18 minutes.”

In TED’s video collection I found the following thought-provoking talk by Conrad Wolfram (of Wolfram Research), in which Conrad makes a logical, persuasive argument for using computers to teach real mathematics.

In his talk, Conrad asks the provocative question, “What is math?” He answers his own question with what he feels are the components of mathematics:

  1. posing the right question
  2. real world to math formulation
  3. calculation
  4. math formulation, referring back to the real world, and verification.

Conrad feels that we spend too much time on step 3—calculation—and not enough time on steps 1, 2, and 4. Further, he feels that if we use computers correctly, they can relieve us of the time we spend on calculations so that we can devote more time to the other steps. I completely agree that, given the ubiquity of computers in education, we should try to harness the power of the computer more.

Students work at a computerThe Common Core State Standards endorse the use of “graphing utilities, spreadsheets, computer algebra systems, and dynamic geometry software…to model purely mathematical phenomena as well as physical phenomena.” This means that, to meet the standards, procedural and calculation-based curricula will need to be rewritten as problems-based curricula in which students must seek out appropriate tools in order to solve problems. The Common Core’s standard for Modeling calls for students to link their mathematics “to everyday life, work, and decision-making.” Some examples for modeling in geometry include:

  • using geometric shapes, their measures, and their properties to describe objects (e.g. modeling a tree trunk or a human torso as a cylinder)
  • applying concepts of density based on area and volume in modeling situations (e.g. persons per square mile, BTUs per cubic foot)
  • applying geometric methods to solve design problems (e.g. designing an object or structure to satisfy physical constraints or minimize cost; working with typographic grid systems based on ratios).

Conrad believes that mathematics is not equivalent to calculations, which can be performed with a computer, and I concur. Recently, on a panel about the use of technology in math education, I, too, made the important distinction between mathematics and arithmetic. Moreover, I asked the audience what they would like their students to do after high school: solve rich problems, or show how to calculate lines upon lines of numbers. They all agreed that they would like to see their students solve rich mathematical problems, not perform calculations.

Conrad suggests that teachers use programming as a way to gauge students’ understanding of procedures and processes, an approach that worked well in my own classroom. When I taught the law of sines to my trigonometry classes, I also taught them how to write programs on a TI-83+. The resultant unit project was to write a program for the law of sines. Not all students came up with the same program; some had basic programs that showed their basic understanding of programming and the law of sines, while others had more developed programs that allowed them to take into account the ambiguous case. Those who had a thorough understanding of the law of sines and how to use it wrote wonderful programs.

Conrad Wolfram and the Common Core want to make mathematics a subject that serves our students well beyond their schooling years. This can be done with more practical problems and a curriculum that stresses conceptual, rather than computational, understanding. To achieve this, we educators must strive for higher levels—and, therefore, richer forms—of mathematics.

One thought on “Mathematics > Computation”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *